I Thought I Failed — Until I Realized the System Failed Me as A Deaf Mom

Blog post quotation: "Over time, I realized I didn't fail, the system failed me. I walked into my second birth fully aware of my worth, my rights, and my voice. And that shift changed EVERYTHING for me as a Deaf mom."

by Kristin Wilks

My name is Kristin. I am Deaf with Cochlear implants and I use both spoken English and ASL. My husband Steven is Deaf and is a fully ASL user.

In 2021, my first pregnancy and birth happened during the height of the COVID pandemic, which was a time filled with restrictions, masks, and so much uncertainty. As a Deaf mom, I struggled with a lack of accessible education, resources, and support. I truly believe my first birth experience was shaped by unnecessary interventions, a lack of informed consent, and communication barriers. Because of this, I wasn’t able to bond with my first baby in the way I had hoped.

For a long time, I carried the heavy feeling that I had failed. I didn’t feel fully part of my own birth or postpartum experience, and it left me wondering: What could I have done differently? What could have made it better? 

As first time Deaf parents, we wanted to take a childbirth education class. My midwife provided a free childbirth education class and we requested an ASL interpreter. The instructor tried to get the interpreter set up on the laptop but we struggled getting an interpreter on the laptop and the instructor was also wearing a mask. We missed out on a lot of important information from the class. I felt like we weren’t fully educated enough about labor and delivery, and I didn’t know what to expect or how to prepare for it in every way of how things would go in labor and delivery. 

We had both tested positive for COVID two weeks before labor but we recovered and we were negative by the time we were admitted. Still, the nurses treated us as if we were contagious, and there were strict restrictions in place for our labor and delivery. We couldn’t even have an in-person interpreter so we had to use the rolling iPad stand for interpretation provided by the hospital. The experience felt even more confusing because of all the barriers — lack of communication, resources, and support. Everyone was wearing masks, which made it impossible for us to read lips or facial expressions. It was hard for us to communicate and discuss options and the risks. 

Kristin Wilks During Delivery of Her Son. Surgical staff assist Kristin while she watches an ASL interpreter through a screen.
Kristin During Delivery of Her Son

In the Labor & Delivery room, I made it to 10 cm and was ready to push but then the nurse was worried about the baby’s heart rate dropping, and before I could fully understand what was happening, I was being rushed into the operating room. The nurses took the rolling iPad stand with them, leaving my Deaf husband behind in the patient room completely confused and worried about what was happening. One of the nurses tried to explain, but without an interpreter, he couldn’t fully understand and was left anxious and confused.

Kristin Wilks and her husband Steven after the birth of their son. They are in the operating room and both are wearing masks. Steven also has full protective wear on.
Kristin and Steven After the Birth of Their Son

The nurse handed him a full PPE suit, so he assumed he needed to put everything on, even the head cover and gloves, before joining me in the operating room. When he finally arrived into the operating room, he found the iPad nearly dead and had to scramble to find an outlet to plug it in. Then he found the outlet to plug in and the battery kept bouncing between 1% and 2% because the iPad was in use and charging so slowly. The whole experience felt traumatic, stressful, and incredibly isolating for both of us. 

After the baby was born in the recovery room, we had to rely on family members to listen to the baby’s cries during the first and second nights. We wanted a more intimate experience, focusing on our baby together, but that wasn’t possible. When we were discharged and went home, I stayed up all night, making sure I didn’t miss any of his cries through our alarm system. 

The next morning, we took our son to his first pediatrician appointment. He had bloodwork done, and we went back home afterward. About an hour later, I received a phone call from the doctor telling us that he had jaundice and needed to return to the hospital for light treatment. He had to stay in an incubator under phototherapy lights for 24 hours. 

When we arrived at the hospital, we were placed in a very small patient room because the hospital was full due to COVID. The room had only one recliner chair, which meant only one person could stay overnight with the baby. Steven couldn’t stay with us overnight, which added to my anxiety. I was just sitting there feeling so exhausted and worried, thinking, “How will I know if he’s crying if I try to take a nap here?” I stayed awake the entire time, anxious about missing his cries. I barely slept at all and could not function well during my C-section recovery and postpartum.

After my first birth experience, I often think back to my first birth experience. I wasn’t educated enough about labor and delivery such as the stages, the pain management options, or the tools that could help me to have a positive birth experience. I didn’t know what to expect or how to prepare for it. I didn’t even know what a doula was back then. I remember being in labor and seeing a flyer taped to the hospital door that said, “Dial-a-Doula Program — Free volunteer doula available,” and wondering, What is a doula? 

My first birth experience pushed me to research and learn everything I could about birth and support to make sure that next time, I felt informed and empowered. Over nearly three years, I researched, watched countless birth videos, talked to midwives, and connected with different doulas until I found a CODA doula, Brittany, who communicates in both spoken English and ASL. She was truly the perfect fit for our family’s communication needs and dynamic. It wasn’t easy finding a doula who understood both of our languages. But from the very beginning, Brittany supported us through every stage from pregnancy, labor and delivery, and postpartum.

When I found out I was pregnant, I contacted her right away. We met in person, and we instantly clicked. She educated us about the whole birth process, labor tools, pain management, and advocacy. She was also an amazing guide, always sharing helpful information, links, and guidance that made me feel prepared and confident for every step of my journey. More than anything, she made me feel seen, heard, and supported.

This time, I wanted to do things differently.

I made my own choices about how I wanted my birth to go and created a birth plan based on my desires. I reached out to the Office of Patient Experience to request a baby cry alert system for labor and delivery room. I explained my first birth experience and the reasons why this system was important for us and future Deaf and Hard of Hearing patients. The Office of Patient Experience approved my request and provided the baby cry alert system, which gave me a huge sense of relief. Then I also learned about the stages of labor, comfort measures, breathing techniques, and more through meetings with my doula, Brittany. She guided me and discussed all of these aspects with me to help me prepare for birth not just physically, but mentally and emotionally.

When we got into the labor and delivery room, I saw that same flyer again, the one that started it all. Brittany noticed it too and pointed at it with a smile. I was having contractions and wanted to tell her through my breathing, “That’s how it all began for me. I didn’t want just some random free doula — I wanted you.” Because she wasn’t just anyone. She understood both ASL and spoken English, and she understood us. She was exactly who we needed. 

And this time, I got the birth I had always dreamed of: calm, beautiful, and full of love. When our baby daughter was born, I felt so much peace and gratitude. It was the most healing and empowering experience, one that reminded me how important the right support can be. I finally had the birth I had hoped for all along, surrounded by people who truly understood and respected me.

Kristin Wilks and her husband after the birth of their daughter. Kristin sits up in a hospital bed holding the baby while Steven supports the baby's head. Their doula Brittany is also at the bedside, touching Kristin's arm and giving the "I love you" ASL sign.
Kristin and Steven After the Birth of Their Daughter, Along With Their Doula Brittany at the Hospital Bedside—Brittany Signs “I Love You” in ASL

I’m so proud of how I navigated this journey, advocating for my rights, needs, goals, and boundaries and for giving myself the care, support, and voice I deserved. I’m so grateful for my ASL doula who believed in me, gave me hope, and guided me to have such a healing and empowering birth after the emotional difficulty of my first pregnancy and birth experience.

Over time, I realized I didn’t fail, the system failed me. I walked into my second birth fully aware of my worth, my rights, and my voice. And that shift changed everything for me as a Deaf mom. Every Deaf parent deserves to feel as supported and understood as we did. I hope my story helps raise awareness, inspire more accessible and inclusive care for all Deaf families.

A Silent Pandemic

Dylan stands in a blazer and jeans crossing his arms and smiling at the camera. There's fall foliage behind him.

by Dylan Ward

While everyone was busy preparing for the pandemic, I lost my hearing.

I’ve been living in silence now for about two months. I am hard-of-hearing and up until recently, I wore a hearing aid in my left ear; there’s negligible residual hearing in my right ear, in which I did not wear a hearing aid. Around mid-March, I sustained an injury to the head and because of the structure of my inner ear anatomy, the injury took away the residual hearing in my left ear.

I’ve been a stay-at-home dad to my seven-year-old son since he was two. It hasn’t always been easy for me as a parent. I don’t have the luxury other parents have with hearing their child in any situation. I’ve always worked harder to communicate with my energetic, stubborn son.

We were building a playhouse and I was careless, letting a board fall. Over the next days and weeks my husband and I visited the urgent care and ear specialists. Everywhere displayed coronavirus warnings and bottles of hand sanitizers reached for our hands. Some staff members wore masks and I was crestfallen. Without my husband, communication would have been impossible. Mask-covered lips are unthinkable for the deaf and hard-of-hearing.

Medicine and healing did not restore my hearing. Small adjustments were made at home since I couldn’t move easily with my vestibular imbalance and frequent rest was required. None of us knew enough sign language to communicate but we were patient with lip reading, sometimes reminding my son to slow down.

I began to wonder what it would be like with silence indefinitely, to parent a child I couldn’t hear. There were certainly worse things that could have happened to me. But I wanted to hear my son again. My Otologist encouraged a cochlear implant. Initially, I’d ignored the cochlear implant information sent home with me. They implied something I wasn’t ready for. How could I possibly have surgery in the middle of all of this? It also worried my son too, in ways I had not realized. I wanted to avoid it all, to simply get my hearing back. Over time, though, I accepted the situation and as I researched cochlear implants, I became less resistant.

The day of the surgery was exciting and daunting and strict protocols were in place for the hospital. My husband was not allowed to assist me in pre-op, but this time I was prepared. I’d installed a special captioning app on my phone with pen and paper at the ready. The app failed, of course, with poor reception. Handwriting everything seemed it would be too cumbersome for everyone on a schedule. Thankfully, the nurses and doctors pulled down their masks to speak, allowing me to lip read. The mask I wore probably put them at ease.

Recovery from surgery wasn’t easy. And I’ve never felt more disabled than I have these past few months. I couldn’t imagine going anywhere like I did before. My husband assumed the small tasks and errands I once handled, both to help me and to keep us all safe. He’s also done his best to work in a limited capacity and provide income.

It’s been challenging to parent an active child sequestered at home. The quarantine has forced me to parent in ways I had not anticipated between managing homeschool, daily home life, and taking care of myself in recovery. Homeschooling has been our biggest struggle. Online instructional videos are not captioned; virtual chats with teachers are out of the question. My son, who once loved going to school everyday, tired quickly of distance learning. The computer couldn’t replicate his classmates or teacher. He desperately craved that social interaction he’d lost and it hurt to see him hurting.

Everything that’s happened has put my disability into a different perspective. It made me realize how limited I really am, or have always been, both at home and elsewhere. It had been hard to hear my son before, but now I couldn’t hear him at all. I wouldn’t know if he was crying in another room. I’m tense and worried when he goes outside to play, constantly peeking out the windows just to be sure he’s okay.

My husband misses being able to communicate with me. My son misses normal routines. Sometimes he forgets daddy really can’t hear now and turns away when frustrated. Then I get frustrated and wear myself out with an upset child. Oftentimes I interrupt conversations without realizing it. At times my son has taken advantage of my inability to hear, sneaking around the house and hiding when in trouble or taking an extra treat when not allowed. But he’s seven. Sometimes I let this slip, sometimes I don’t. We’re already stressed from these unusual times, so I give my son a little leeway. I have to let him do something he doesn’t normally get to do. No one is harmed from it and this gives us small moments of happy.

I’m hopeful for the future, that the cochlear implant will enable me to hear in new and improved ways. I’ve adapted to a world that cannot be together like we once did. I stay connected with family and friends via texts and emails. My son has embraced virtual learning more with a few adjustments made and he has fun with it. He’s been writing letters or sending funny pictures to friends and happily gets them in return. He’s also been helping daddy more and taking his time to communicate. We laugh at silly things I didn’t hear correctly and we cry for things we miss.

What is most important is letting him enjoy his childhood in a time like this no matter what is happening to daddy, who loves him always. My son is most comforted when I’m just with him. My presence makes him feel okay. I hold him and keep him calm. We just let ourselves be here, together.

Parenting During Social Distancing for the HoH Parent

by Ellen Levitt (April 2020)

As a veteran New York City public high school teacher, I’ve worked with several HoH (hard of hearing) students, especially at Murry Bergtraum High School in Lower Manhattan, where American Sign Language was a Language offering. Some HoH students had signers who travelled with them from classroom to classroom, others didn’t, but they were a regular presence in my social studies classes in the 1990s. My typical strategy was seating these students within the front row, and I would make eye contact frequently.

When I was a high school student myself, I was in classes with HoH students (and others who had a variety of physical disabilities, including cerebral palsy and legal blindness) at Edward R. Murrow High School in Brooklyn. Being around students who had different types of physical abilities made all of us more aware of how people adapt and achieve in their own manner.

Recently I interviewed S, who is HoH, a single parent of three school age children, and a Murrow HS graduate like myself (although our years at the school did not overlap). S has been documenting on social media, often humorously, what it’s like to deal with children during the Coronavirus pandemic and social distancing. His two daughters are ages 12 and 11, and his son is almost 8 years old.

Online learning, especially when it is the primary form of education, has pros and cons. If the child has regular access to a device, be it a desktop, laptop or pad/notebook, and has reliable internet power, then the situation is certainly workable. Students are getting their assignments online in a few different manners: often they get posted written assignments and email in homework; sometimes they “attend” live or pre-recorded lectures or interactive teleconferences, or watch assignments culled from the web, YouTube or educational websites.

For any parent, there can be difficulties in making sure the child or children are doing their work, understanding the course material, and being disciplined enough to get through material. Add in the different atmosphere, the changes in socializing, and related issues, and it can be difficult. How is it for a family of three, with a parent who is Hard of Hearing, even if the children do not have special needs?

Here are some of S’s thoughts on how the current social distancing limitations have impacted his family life and his children’s education:

1. What are some difficulties you have with getting your kids to do schoolwork and chores under quarantine?

Haven’t really had too many difficulties. They’ve helped out a great deal because we’ve all been home a lot. The main difficulty is getting the kids to stop playing Roblox or Fortnite, or watch YouTube during class. I’ve caught all three doing it, and it’s very frustrating.

2. How does being a parent with HoH impact dealing with teachers and other school staff?

It hasn’t really impacted my interactions with them. Probably because there isn’t much these days! In the past it was all on the phone, and I don’t “do phone” too well because I’m deaf. Now they’re all receptive to text, WhatsApp chats, etc.

3. How would you compare your children’s experiences with school to your own?

I went to school during a time when there wasn’t the internet. The internet didn’t really take off until I got to college, so it was a dramatically different time. My oldest loves doing (schooling) remotely, from her bedroom– in fact, a bit too much!

4. Other thoughts?

It will be interesting to see if any innovations come out of this that are carried over when we lift all this social distancing stuff because of the coronavirus. One thing that I think is overlooked is interactions with fellow classmates. That’s hard to do in a Zoom classroom with 15 other kids. However, my daughters have private chat rooms with their classmates (no teachers) so they can ask for help from classmates if needed. However, it’s not the same as person to person contact.

S has posted on Facebook about what the New York Times has labeled “the parental stress of remote learning” and general disciplining of children now:

“Homeschooling Day 14: Today’s lecture series consists of “No, You Can’t Wear A Balloon Giraffe To Class.

Homeschooling Day 12 Update: Sent kid to office. He threw a temper tantrum because I couldn’t look at the painting he made for me in “class.” I was busy cleaning up the paint that he left all over the chair, the dining room table, and the floor…

Today’s lecture series consists of “Watching YouTube Does Not Count As Homework.”

Homeschooling Day 9 update: Today’s lecture series is entitled, “You Can’t Play Roblox During Recess Because You Already Spend Six Hours A Day on the Laptop In Class and You Want to Spend MORE Time On A Screen?

Homeschooling Day 4: Our homeschool curriculum includes my lecture series entitled “Yes, You Still Have to Brush Your Teeth Even Though We Aren’t Going Anywhere.” Also, when you look around for the math teacher and then realize…you’re the math teacher.

Homeschooling Day 3 Mini Update: Had to suspend a kid for dress code violation (wore pajamas)

Homeschooling Day 3: Two students suspended for fighting. Teacher fired for drinking on the job.

Homeschooling Day 2: Trying to see if I can get kids transferred out of my class,

Survived Day 1 of Homeschooling. Barely. Lol. Playing Rummikub with the kids!

It is also tiring and challenging for S to do his own work (which is now online) while juggling his kids’ schooltime. This is parental engagement amped up ever stronger. The roles include not only teacher but counselor, cafeteria worker, technical support and more.

S and all other parents are concerned about their children maintaining their studies and not falling behind (or not too much). The short term and long term impacts will no doubt be analyzed in the months and years to come.